David Bednar and Ryan Jeffers Accept Qualifying Offers as Six Others Decline: 2027 Fantasy Fallout for the Yankees Closer Job and the Twins Catching Split
By Verdexed MLB Desk
Yankees closer David Bednar and Twins catcher Ryan Jeffers accepted their one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offers before Tuesday's 4 p.m. ET deadline, the only two of the eight players tendered offers to take them. The other six declined: Randy Arozarena, Seiya Suzuki, Brandon Lowe, Trevor Rogers and Adrian Morejon are now free agents with draft-pick compensation attached, and Jake Bauers had already signed a four-year, $58 million deal with Boston. For fantasy players looking ahead to 2027, the two acceptances settle a closer job and complicate a catching situation, while the declines set up the first wave of the free-agent market.
The decisions at a glance
The qualifying offer is a one-year contract at a set salary that teams can extend to their own pending free agents. If the player declines and signs elsewhere, his former team receives draft-pick compensation, which can chill a player's market. This year's results split along familiar lines.
| Player | 2026 team | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| David Bednar | Yankees | Accepted |
| Ryan Jeffers | Twins | Accepted |
| Randy Arozarena | Mariners | Declined |
| Seiya Suzuki | Cubs | Declined |
| Brandon Lowe | Pirates | Declined |
| Trevor Rogers | Orioles | Declined |
| Adrian Morejon | Padres | Declined |
| Jake Bauers | Brewers | Declined, signed with Red Sox |
One wrinkle hangs over the entire offseason. The collective bargaining agreement expires on December 1, and owners could impose a lockout that freezes transactions. Players who accepted a one-year deal now have certainty through that uncertainty, and both Bednar and Jeffers are expected to return to free agency after 2027.
David Bednar: the Yankees' closer job is settled
Bednar was excellent in his first full season in New York, posting a 2.47 ERA with 35 saves in 64 appearances. He has been one of the most dependable closers in baseball since taking over the ninth inning in Pittsburgh in 2022, and accepting the offer removes any uncertainty about who finishes games for the Yankees in 2027.
Fantasy take: This is the best possible outcome for Bednar's 2027 draft value. Closers who change teams in the winter often face a murky role or a new manager's preferences. Bednar avoids all of that: he returns to a contender with an established job and a team that will generate plenty of save chances. He should be drafted as a top-tier closer, and his ADP should rise now that his role is locked in. The risk factors are age (he is 32) and the general volatility of relief pitching, but job security is the most important trait for a closer, and he has it.
Ryan Jeffers: certainty in salary, not in playing time
Jeffers had a productive season, hitting .256/.353/.461 with 14 home runs and 56 RBIs in 92 games. He was widely projected to land a multiyear deal in the range of four years and $75 million, so accepting a one-year offer was a surprise. It gives him a large salary and another shot at free agency, but it also brings back the issue that has limited his fantasy value.
Fantasy take: Jeffers essentially split time with Victor Caratini last season, and Caratini is also returning to Minnesota. That means another timeshare is likely. Ninety-two games is a meaningful sample, and his on-base skills and power make him a useful catcher in two-catcher leagues and on-base percentage formats. In one-catcher leagues, though, the platoon caps his counting stats. Draft him as a mid-tier catcher with upside if the Twins tilt the playing time in his favor.
The declines: who to watch
Randy Arozarena is the most fantasy-relevant hitter on the market. His blend of power and speed has made him a reliable source of multi-category production, and his landing spot will shape his 2027 value, particularly if he moves to a more hitter-friendly park.
Seiya Suzuki brings power and on-base skills. Where he signs and where he hits in the lineup will determine his RBI and run opportunities.
Brandon Lowe is a power-hitting infielder whose qualifying offer status comes with a twist: if he signs elsewhere for $50 million or more, Pittsburgh receives a 2027 draft pick between the first round and Competitive Balance Round A. That compensation level could influence how aggressively teams pursue him.
Trevor Rogers and Adrian Morejon are the pitchers to watch. Rogers' landing spot will determine whether he enters 2027 drafts as a rotation piece with a defined role, and Morejon's will decide whether he is a setup man or a candidate for save chances. Relievers who change teams sometimes find a closing role, so Morejon is one to follow closely.
Jake Bauers, last month's NLCS MVP, has already found his new home in Boston on a four-year, $58 million deal.
The Verdexed angle
The qualifying offer process is the first real signal of how the 2027 fantasy landscape will look. Bednar's decision locks in one of the most reliable sources of saves heading into drafts. Jeffers' decision keeps him in a known situation, which makes his value easier to project but keeps his ceiling capped. The declines will play out over the coming weeks, and possibly over a longer timeline if a lockout freezes the market after December 1.
Verdexed's MLB coverage will follow every signing that shifts fantasy value for 2027. Check the MLB predictions page once the season approaches for the model's views on team outcomes.
What to do in your league
- Upgrade David Bednar in early 2027 rankings and dynasty formats. Job security is the most valuable trait a closer can have. - Keep Ryan Jeffers in the mid-tier at catcher, with a playing-time discount for the Caratini timeshare. - Track Arozarena and Suzuki's landing spots, the two hitters most likely to change fantasy tiers based on their new parks. - Watch Adrian Morejon for a possible save opportunity with a new team. - Plan for a slow market. A lockout after December 1 could delay most of these decisions until later in the winter.