Shane Steichen Won't Commit to Daniel Jones After the 26-3 Loss in Houston: What an Anthony Richardson Start Would Mean for Jonathan Taylor and the Colts Against the Giants
By Verdexed NFL Desk

The Indianapolis Colts have a quarterback decision to make before they host the New York Giants in Week 12. After Daniel Jones completed 12 of 27 passes for 144 yards and an interception in Thursday's 26-3 loss at Houston, coach Shane Steichen pulled him with under eight minutes left and sent in Anthony Richardson for one series. Afterward, Steichen declined to commit to Jones as the starter, saying the staff would evaluate everything and that Jones could have done some things better. At 3-8, the Colts are running out of reasons to keep the status quo, and fantasy managers with Jonathan Taylor or any Indianapolis receiver need to understand what a change would mean.
How Thursday unfolded
Indianapolis scored on its opening drive, a 34-yard Spencer Shrader field goal, and never scored again. Houston's defense dominated, holding the Colts to 21 rushing yards from Taylor on 11 carries and sacking Jones in the end zone for a safety. Jones' interception was reportedly his 13th of the season, among the highest totals in the league.
Richardson's cameo did not settle anything. He took over at the Indianapolis 39 for one series: a 2-yard run and two incompletions, then a punt. Coverage of the game across outlets agreed that nothing in the brief appearance changed the quarterback picture on its own.
| Quarterback | Thursday vs Houston |
|---|---|
| Daniel Jones | 12/27, 144 yds, 0 TD, 1 INT |
| Anthony Richardson | 1 series, 2 incomplete, 1 run for 2 yds |
The case for a change, and the case against
The case for Richardson is about the run game and the offense's ceiling. Reports out of Indianapolis indicate the Colts have a package of plays built for Richardson that has not been used in games, and that he has been working with the scout-team offense in practice. His rushing ability forces defenses to account for the quarterback on designed runs and read options, which is exactly what a struggling run game needs.
The case against is the track record of this staff. After a 42-7 loss to Jacksonville earlier this season, Steichen stuck with Jones. Several Indianapolis outlets have reported that Steichen is reluctant to turn to Richardson unless absolutely necessary, and the coach's comments Thursday stopped short of a benching. The opponent also matters: Jones facing the Giants, his former team, is a storyline the Colts may want to give him one more chance in.
As of Friday, no Week 12 starter had been named.
Fantasy fallout: Jonathan Taylor
Taylor is the player most affected by this decision. Thursday was one of the worst rushing games of his career, but the context matters: Indianapolis played without both starting tackles, Bernhard Raimann (concussion) and Jalen Travis (knee), and fell behind by multiple scores early. Taylor's backup, Seth McGowan, left with a hamstring injury, which consolidates the workload if McGowan misses time.
A Richardson start would likely help Taylor's efficiency. Defenses that must respect a quarterback keeper on zone-read looks cannot crowd the line of scrimmage as easily, and Taylor's best seasons have come with a mobile quarterback. The tradeoff is that Richardson could vulture short rushing touchdowns, which caps Taylor's scoring upside somewhat.
Either way, Taylor stays in fantasy lineups. The Giants matchup at home is more forgiving than Houston on the road, and his talent and role are not in question.
Fantasy fallout: the passing game
The Colts receivers are the hardest players to evaluate. Jones has offered a modest but steady floor through short completions; Richardson's profile is more volatile, with more deep attempts and a lower completion rate. That shifts value toward downfield receivers and away from possession options and tight ends.
Until a starter is named, no Colts receiver should be in a fantasy lineup with confidence. If Richardson is announced, the downfield threats become boom-or-bust WR3 types; if Jones keeps the job, the short-area options regain a modest PPR floor.
Richardson in fantasy: If he is named the starter, he immediately becomes a viable two-quarterback and superflex option, and a deep-league streamer in one-quarterback formats, because his rushing gives him a floor most backups lack. He is worth a speculative add in superflex leagues now.
Where the season stands
At 3-8, Indianapolis sits behind 7-2 Jacksonville and 4-6 Houston in the AFC South, and the realistic path to the postseason is narrowing with each loss. That changes the calculus. A team still in the hunt protects its floor; a team drifting out of contention can afford to find out what it has in a younger quarterback over the final six weeks.
That is why the pressure for a change is likely to build if Week 12 goes badly, even if Jones keeps the job against the Giants. Fantasy managers playing for a title should plan as if the Colts quarterback could change at any point in the final month.
Betting angle
The quarterback decision is the biggest variable in the Colts-Giants line. Markets will likely wait for an announcement before moving significantly. A Richardson start typically adds uncertainty and can push totals in either direction; for bettors, the edge comes from reacting quickly once the decision is public. For Verdexed's view on Colts games, the model's live probabilities are at /nfl/predictions, and the Week 12 picks page will be posted at its usual weekly address once the slate is set.
What's next
Watch for Steichen's comments early next week and the first Week 12 practice report. If Richardson takes first-team reps, the switch is likely. Fantasy managers should keep Taylor in lineups, make a speculative Richardson add in superflex formats, and leave Colts receivers on benches until the picture clears.