Back to Blog
Start/SitNFL logoNFL2026-11-19

Joe Milton Gets His Second Start as the Eagles Host Pittsburgh: Fantasy Outlook for Saquon Barkley, the Steelers Receivers and a Sub-40 Total

By Verdexed NFL Desk

Will Joe Milton III, 10, or Sam Howell, 16, win the Cowboys' QB2 job behind Dak Prescott?
Photo: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images, via ESPN (editorial)

The Philadelphia Eagles are sticking with Joe Milton at quarterback. Head coach Nick Sirianni announced Wednesday that Milton will make his second career start for Philadelphia on Sunday at Lincoln Financial Field against the Pittsburgh Steelers (1 p.m. ET). For fantasy managers, the decision locks in a run-heavy, mistake-avoidant Eagles game plan, keeps Saquon Barkley as the only Philadelphia skill player with a dependable weekly floor, and frames one of the lowest totals on the Week 11 board.

The Steelers, meanwhile, may get two receivers back from injured reserve. Michael Pittman Jr. and Roman Wilson both returned to practice this week, and that changes the outlook for a Pittsburgh passing game that looked broken in a 38-18 loss to Cincinnati.

Why Philadelphia is staying with Milton

The Eagles are 2-7, have lost seven straight and are coming off their bye. Jalen Hurts has not played since early in the season because of blood clots, and multiple reports have indicated he is expected to miss the rest of 2026, though outlets have described the clots differently. That leaves Philadelphia playing out the string with a developmental quarterback whose arm talent has never been in question.

Milton's first start, a 19-11 loss to the Giants in Week 9, showed both sides of that profile. He threw for 169 yards and ran for 64, was sacked seven times and lost a fumble. Accounts of his final passing line differ slightly on whether he threw an interception, but the theme was consistent: the legs created yards, the processing behind a leaky protection unit did not. Milton said after the bye that his confidence in the offense has grown, and Sirianni's decision suggests the staff wants a longer look before the offseason.

The bigger issue in that Giants game was the supporting cast. DeVonta Smith and Dontayvion Wicks were both unavailable, which left Milton throwing to a thin group. Their practice participation this week is the first thing to check before setting a lineup.

Fantasy fallout: Eagles

Saquon Barkley is the clear start. He scored on a 3-yard run against the Giants and remains the focal point of an offense that will lean on the ground game to protect a young quarterback. The concern is efficiency, not volume: an offense that cannot threaten downfield invites eight-man boxes, and a Pittsburgh front with T.J. Watt and Cam Heyward (both rested Wednesday rather than injured) can make life hard. Treat Barkley as an RB2 with touchdown upside rather than a locked-in RB1.

Milton himself is a superflex-only dart. Rushing production gives him a floor in two-quarterback formats, but seven sacks in his only start and a modest passing ceiling keep him off one-QB radars.

Eagles receivers are bench-or-fade until Smith is confirmed active. If Smith plays, he becomes a low-end WR3 because the target tree narrows behind him. If he sits again, no Philadelphia receiver merits a start.

Fantasy fallout: Steelers

Pittsburgh enters 6-3 but battered. Aaron Rodgers opened the Cincinnati loss 0-for-8, the worst start of his career by that measure, and finished 15-of-29 for 143 yards with two late touchdowns. The Steelers also lost left guard Mason McCormick to injured reserve after he was driven into Rodgers on a sack, so protection is a question here too.

The receiver returns matter most. Pittman (foot) and Wilson (finger) are both eligible to come off injured reserve, and coach Mike McCarthy said he would evaluate their work through the week before deciding.

Steelers playerInjuryWednesday status
Michael Pittman Jr.Foot (IR)Returned to practice
Roman WilsonFinger (IR)Full
Nick HerbigHip, ribsDid not practice
Patrick QueenHandLimited
DeShon ElliottKneeLimited
Jalen RamseyPersonalDid not practice

If Pittman is activated, he slides back in as a WR3 in a game where volume, not efficiency, is the case for him. Wilson is a deep-league flex only. Rodgers is a low-end QB2 even against a 2-7 opponent, because Pittsburgh's game script should be conservative with a lead.

The Steelers defense is the best start in this game. A pass rush led by Watt is exactly the matchup Philadelphia's seven-sack showing against the Giants warns about, and a lost fumble was part of Milton's first start. Even with Herbig limited or out, Pittsburgh D/ST is a top-10 play this week.

Betting angle

The market has Pittsburgh around a 4.5-point road favorite, with the total sitting near 38.5 (some books show 37.5 or 39). Pittsburgh is 6-3 against the spread; Philadelphia is 1-8. Those numbers explain why the line has not moved much toward the Eagles despite Pittsburgh's ugly Week 10.

The more interesting bet is the total. Two offenses with real quarterback questions, a home team that wants to shorten the game and a road team with protection issues all point the same direction. If Pittman and Smith both sit, the under case strengthens further. Bettors who like Philadelphia should note the Eagles have not covered with any regularity this season, and a home underdog with a first-year starter is not a profile that has historically rewarded faith.

The Verdexed model take

The Verdexed model publishes its full Week 11 board, including this game, at /blog/nfl-week-11-picks-2026, with live win probabilities at /nfl/predictions. For fantasy purposes, the structural read is simple: this is a game to own defenses and running backs from, not passing games.

What to do in your league

- Start: Saquon Barkley (RB2), Steelers D/ST. - Monitor: Michael Pittman Jr.'s activation, DeVonta Smith's practice status through Friday. - Sit: Aaron Rodgers in one-QB leagues, all Eagles receivers unless Smith is cleared, Roman Wilson outside deep leagues. - Superflex only: Joe Milton, on the strength of his rushing.

The final injury reports land Friday. If both Pittman and Smith are ruled out, lean harder into the defenses and the under.

Want more analysis?

Check out our predictions and DFS tools powered by the same quantitative engine.